Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler
Heat pumps get a lot of attention these days, and you might be wondering whether it’s time to ditch your gas boiler. It’s a fair question, and the answer depends a lot on your home, your budget and how long you plan to stay put.
There’s plenty of hype on both sides. Heat pumps aren’t a magic fix for every home, and gas boilers aren’t going to disappear overnight.
Here at Boilerhut, we install boilers across the country every day and speak to homeowners weighing up exactly this choice. Here’s our straight-talking guide to heat pump vs gas boiler.
Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler: Key Points
- A gas boiler is much cheaper to install, and our fixed-price combi swaps start from £2,196 including VAT.
- A heat pump costs more upfront, but a £7,500 Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant is available in England and Wales.
- At current prices, running costs are similar for a gas boiler and a well-designed heat pump.
- Heat pumps work best in well-insulated homes, often with bigger radiators or underfloor heating.
- There’s no ban on replacing an existing gas boiler with a new one.
- Need a new gas boiler? Get a quick online quote for a fixed price.
Is a heat pump or gas boiler better?
For most existing UK homes on mains gas, a new gas boiler is still the most practical and affordable choice. It’s cheaper to install, it works with your existing radiators, and it heats your home quickly.
A heat pump can be a great option if your home is well insulated, you’re planning a renovation anyway, or you want to cut your carbon footprint and are happy to invest upfront. It’s not the right answer for every home, though, and it’s worth getting proper advice before you switch.
How does a heat pump compare to a gas boiler?
A gas boiler burns gas to heat water, which then flows around your radiators. Modern condensing gas boilers are around 90% efficient or more.
An air source heat pump takes heat from the outside air and concentrates it, using electricity to run a compressor. Because it moves heat rather than creating it, a good heat pump can produce around 3 units of heat for every unit of electricity it uses. That’s what makes it so efficient, although performance drops in very cold weather.
Is a heat pump or gas boiler cheaper to install?
A gas boiler is much cheaper. At Boilerhut, our fixed-price like-for-like combi swaps start from £2,196 including VAT, and that includes removing your old boiler, a chemical flush, a magnetic filter and a wireless thermostat.
An air source heat pump usually costs several times that once you include the unit, a hot water cylinder and any radiator upgrades. The Boiler Upgrade Scheme can take £7,500 off in England and Wales, and off-gas homes switching from oil or LPG can currently get £9,000 until 31 March 2027. You’ll need an MCS-certified installer to claim it.
Is a heat pump or gas boiler cheaper to run?
At the time of writing (October 2026), the Ofgem price cap puts gas at just under 8p per kWh and electricity at around 26p per kWh.
With a gas boiler running at around 90% efficiency, heat costs you roughly 9p per kWh. A heat pump with a seasonal efficiency of around 3 delivers heat for roughly 9p per kWh too. In other words, running costs are very similar at current prices.
A really well-designed heat pump system, or a specialist heat pump tariff, can bring that down further. A poorly designed system in a draughty home can cost more to run than a gas boiler.
Will a heat pump work in my home instead of a gas boiler?
Heat pumps run at lower temperatures than gas boilers, so they work best in homes that hold their heat well. Before switching, it’s worth asking:
- Is your home well insulated, with decent loft and wall insulation?
- Do you have space outside for the heat pump unit and inside for a hot water cylinder?
- Are your radiators big enough, or would some need upgrading?
- Are you happy for your home to be heated gently for longer, rather than quick blasts of heat?
If the answer to most of those is no, a new gas boiler is likely to be the better fit for now.
Heat pump vs gas boiler: what are the pros and cons?
Gas boiler pros:
- Much cheaper to install.
- Works with your existing radiators and pipework.
- Heats your home quickly, even in very cold weather.
- A combi needs no hot water cylinder, saving space.
Gas boiler cons:
- Burns a fossil fuel, so produces more carbon emissions.
- Not eligible for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant.
Heat pump pros:
- Much lower carbon emissions.
- Grants available to help with installation costs.
- Very efficient when designed and installed well.
Heat pump cons:
- Higher upfront cost, even with a grant.
- Usually needs a hot water cylinder and sometimes bigger radiators.
- Works best in well-insulated homes.
Are gas boilers being banned instead of heat pumps?
No. There’s no ban on replacing an existing gas boiler with a new one, and you can still buy and install gas boilers today. The changes being introduced mainly affect new-build homes, which are moving towards low-carbon heating.
So if your gas boiler has broken down or is getting old, replacing it with a modern, efficient gas boiler is still a perfectly sensible choice.
Which gas boiler would we recommend instead of a heat pump?
For most homes, we recommend a Viessmann boiler. The Vitodens range uses a stainless steel heat exchanger, it’s highly efficient, and when we fit a Vitodens 100-W combi you get a 12-year warranty. A fitted Vitodens 050-W 25kW combi from Boilerhut is £2,696 including VAT.
If you’re thinking about a heat pump in the future, our guide to heat pumps vs solar panels is a good place to start.
Who installs gas boilers and heat pumps?
Gas boilers must be installed by a Gas Safe registered engineer. Heat pumps should be installed by an MCS-certified installer if you want to claim the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant.
At Boilerhut, we have local Gas Safe registered engineers and OFTEC registered engineers all over the country, ready to install every type of boiler, including gas boilers, oil boilers and LPG boilers. You get a fixed price, no hidden extras, and you can spread the cost with boiler finance.
Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler: Our Verdict
Heat pumps have a big part to play in the future of home heating, and they can be a great choice for the right home. But for most existing homes on mains gas, a new gas boiler is still the more affordable and practical option right now, with similar running costs and a much lower upfront price.
If your boiler needs replacing, get a quick online quote and our team will help you find the right boiler for your home.
Need a new boiler at a reasonable price?
If you need a new or replacement boiler or are looking at having a central heating system installed, get an online quote (it takes less than 1 minute), and you’ll get an instant price. But why choose Boilerhut:
- Next day boiler installation.
- Instant, no-obligation quote in less than 1 minute.
- Finance options available for new boilers and central heating installation.
- 10 to 12-year warranty on boilers.
- ‘Excellent’ 5* customer satisfaction on Trustpilot.
- Fixed prices. No hidden extras.
- Get up to three quotes for different-tier boilers.
